As the NFL gears up for its annual Hall of Fame induction ceremony, one name that has been noticeably absent from the list of inductees is none other than Bill Belichick. The legendary coach of the New England Patriots has a long list of accolades and accomplishments, including six Super Bowl championships. So why did one longtime Indianapolis Colts beat reporter decide not to vote for him into the Hall of Fame?
According to Mike Chappell, who has covered the Colts for nearly four decades, his decision to not vote for Belichick was not a personal one, but rather a professional one. In an article published by IndyStar, Chappell explained that he made the difficult decision based on Belichick’s lack of integrity and sportsmanship.
Chappell first pointed to the infamous “Spygate” scandal in 2007, where the Patriots were caught illegally videotaping the New York Jets’ defensive signals. Belichick was fined $500,000 and the Patriots were fined $250,000, and had to forfeit a first-round draft pick. While many have argued that this incident did not affect the Patriots’ success on the field, Chappell believes it goes against the core values of the game.
He also mentioned the “Deflategate” scandal in 2015, where the Patriots were accused of deflating footballs in the AFC Championship game against the Indianapolis Colts. Belichick was once again fined, and the Patriots were forced to forfeit another first-round draft pick and pay a hefty penalty. While the NFL eventually overturned the suspension of quarterback Tom Brady, Chappell believes that Belichick’s involvement in these scandals tarnishes his legacy.
But it’s not just about the scandals. Chappell also spoke about Belichick’s behavior towards the media and his opponents. The coach is notorious for giving short, uninvolved answers during press conferences, often leaving reporters frustrated and unsatisfied. Chappell believes that this lack of respect towards the media, who play a crucial role in promoting the league and its players, is unacceptable.
Furthermore, Chappell recalled a particular incident during a game between the Colts and the Patriots in 2015, where Belichick refused to shake the hand of Colts head coach Chuck Pagano after the game. While some may argue that this is just a small gesture, Chappell believes it speaks volumes about Belichick’s character.
In a league that prides itself on integrity, sportsmanship, and respect, Chappell believes that Belichick falls short in these categories. As a beat reporter, he has seen first-hand the impact that coaches have on their players and the league as a whole. And while Belichick’s success on the field cannot be denied, Chappell believes that it’s important to also consider a coach’s character and conduct when deciding on their induction into the Hall of Fame.
Chappell’s decision not to vote for Belichick into the Hall of Fame may not change the outcome, as the coach is widely expected to be inducted in the near future. But it does raise an important question about the criteria for admittance into the most prestigious club in football. Should a coach’s off-field behavior and conduct be taken into consideration, or should their on-field accomplishments be the sole determining factor?
In the end, it’s up to each individual voter to make their own decision. But Chappell’s stance on Belichick serves as a reminder that the NFL is not just about winning and losing, but also about upholding the values and integrity of the game. And for that, he should be commended.
